 
 
            Leading presidential scholars debate the question: βIs democracy beyond point of no return?β
       
    
      
  
        
        
        
  
  
  
  
  The 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½νβs latest Presidentβs Forum, held Oct. 6 on the Biddeford Campus, convened national and local scholars, students and faculty, professional staff, and engaged community members for a thought-provoking discussion on the endurance of American democracy and the evolution of presidential power.
Hosted by 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½ν President James Herbert, the event β βIs Trump a Strongman President, and Can Our Democracy Endure?β β brought together William G. Howell, Ph.D., dean of the School of Government and Policy at Johns Hopkins University, and Andrew Rudalevige, Ph.D., Thomas Brackett Reed Professor of Government at Bowdoin College, to engage in a debate the role and status of the modern presidency, the administrative state, and the balance of executive and legislative power in contemporary, and future, American democracy.
 
 
(Left): William G. Howell, Ph.D. (Right): Andrew Rudalevige, Ph.D.
Since its inception in 2018, 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½νβs Presidentβs Forum has served as a platform for thoughtful discourse, providing a venue for diverse perspectives on the most pressing issues of our time, ultimately underscoring 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½νβs role in fostering the guiding principles of intellectual humility, curiosity, and civility as part of its Marketplace of Ideas initiative.
In opening remarks, Herbert reflected on the fragility of democratic institutions amid deepening polarization and a growing disregard for long-held political norms. He pointed to the erosion of civil discourse as a fundamental threat to democratic life, in which elected officials on both sides of the aisle have described their opposing parties as βanti-American, dangerous, or even evil.β
 
911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½ν President James D. Herbert
He further noted that recent violence against lawmakers, prominent thought leaders, and civilians committed by and against members from all sides of the political divide has become the culmination of such national discord.
βAll of this rancor has trickled down into our lives, fueling anxiety and bitterness within individuals, families, and communities," he said to an audience of hundreds. βIn short, we are losing the art of civil discourse with those who think differently from us, with potentially devastating consequences for our society."
Following Herbertβs remarks, event moderator Jeanne A.K. Hey, Ph.D., 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½ν dean emerita and CEO of Hey University, convened the event by introducing opening statements from both panelists.
Drawing from his book, Howell explored how decades of growing executive influence have reshaped the balance of power between branches of government, arguing that modern presidents increasingly test the limits of authority, often unrestrained by courts or Congress.
Rudalevige countered that, while recent presidents have expanded their reach, Congress retains the most significant constitutional power β possessing the ability even to fire the president β noting that legislative inaction, rather than diminished authority, may be the greater concern.
 
 
 
 
 
(Clockwise, from top left): President Herbert introduces the eveningβs panelists; 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½ν students listen eagerly; 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½ν Dean Emerita Jeanne Hey, Ph.D., moderates the discussion; a student asks about Americaβs international reputation; and hundreds fill the seats for 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½νβs 10th Presidentβs Forum.
Throughout the evening, the panelists examined whether American institutions are still equipped to check the ambitions of a strong executive and how a divided political culture might reclaim a spirit of shared governance. Discussion further touched on the global implications of U.S. democratic instability, with thoughtful questions from 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½ν students probing how international allies perceive recent political shifts.
Herbert closed his remarks by reaffirming 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½νβs commitment to convening difficult but necessary conversations.
βAt 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½ν, we are committed to doing our part to combat this trend,β he said. βWe proactively foster discourse on difficult topics from a perspective of intellectual humility, curiosity, and civility. One of these programs is the Presidentβs Forum β¦ (and this) kind of dialogue β¦ has never been more critical.β
View the Full Panel Discussion
Has the rise of the so-called βstrongman presidencyβ altered the balance of power in our government? If so, what does that mean for the endurance of our democracy? Presidential scholars William G. Howell, Ph.D., and Andrew Rudalevige, Ph.D., examine these questions and more in 911±¬ΑΟΝψΊμΑμ½νβs latest Presidentβs Forum from Oct. 6, 2025.